An Exchange and Discussion about the stories in EINSTEIN'S BEACH HOUSE by Jacob M. Appel

Saturday, March 4, 2023

DELIVERANCE FROM LIMERENCE

I have considered this project of studying Appel's short story techniques through reading of his collection EINSTEIN'S BEACH HOUSE, a limited study with another writer, The Fire Man. Consequently this commentary on the stories and Appel's technique and style will come to a close about a month from now. I had hoped this blogging experiment would be helpful for the Fire Man, a talented and aspiring young writer, but I think he is finding it to be more of a task than a joy. For myself, I discovered the act of reading a powerful, subliminal teaching tool, and I was hoping our readings and response to each other would be a source of motivation and inspiration.

While waiting for my colleague's response to "Strings," I have moved on to "Limerence" the fourth entry in this eight-story collection. Of all the stories, this one had, perhaps, the most impact for me on a personal level. Limerence, as a psychological condition was not recognized until Psychologist Dorothy Tennov published her study in 1998, Love and Limerence: The Experience of Being in Love. Limerence is described briefly as obsessive thinking about the object of your affection, irrational idolizing their attributes, emotional dependency, and lastly, (and most importantly) longing for reciprocation.

Leave it to Appel, who among his many advanced degrees holds a doctorate in psychology, to clarify my adolescent life that continues to haunt me even today. His story about Jesse's obsession with Lena, pales before the obsessive compulsive behaviors of my adolescent years from junior high school through my years in college. Want to know about "Limerence"? I can give you stories...in spades. But, that's another Blog.

Appel's story of Jesse Neerman growing up in Connecticut with an obsession for Lena Limpetti is well-crafted. Lena had moved to the house across the street when he was in the seventh grade. She was also in the seventh grade, and Jesse's father asked him to show her around and introduce her to friends.

Lena's stepfather was in jail for having killed her mother, and she had come from California to live in Connecticut with her father. We learn these facts abruptly as an element of surprise, as almost everything about Lena is endearing, edgy, with abrupt swings of mood. But she was a stunning beauty. She turned heads, no matter where she goes. She hung out with older boys and enlisted Jesse's help to smooth over and back up her alibis about her whereabouts and boyfriends.

When Lena abruptly leaves for California with a tattoo artist to visit her stepfather who has just been released from prison, Jesse finally gets the courage to write Lena a letter declaring his love for her.  Upon her return, Jesse asks Lena if she received his letter, she replies "I wish I could write like that."  When he asks about the visit with her stepfather, she tells him he hanged himself the day before she arrived.

Years pass, and Jesse marries and has daughters of his own, and after pursuing his law degree at Yale, becomes a Connecticut judge. He has lost touch with Lena, and on a rainy day, Lena's father calls with concern about Lena in Greenwich Village and her refusal to communicate. 

Although he had not seen or been in touch with Lena for years, he agrees to check on her situation in the village. When he arrives, he sees Lena at the cash register. She doesn't recognize him. He walks up to her and says "Lena...it's really you." Suddenly she recognizes him and hugs him, and all of his feelings for her from the past come flooding back into his memory.

She goes through a rush of emotions, becoming angry that maybe he thought he still had a chance with her. She tells him he wasn't the only guy that wrote her love letters. She begins fuming that her father had sent Jesse, screaming, "I don't owe him anything." 

They sit for a few moments, when Jesse says, almost angrily, he has to get back to Connecticut. As Lena reaches for his hand, he avoids her and makes a quick retreat, presumably leaving Lena stunned.

Outside in the "drizzle and mist," Jesse clutches his umbrella, somehow hoping that Lena Limpetti would come "chasing him through the rain."

This is the most complex narrative in this set of stories thus far---passages of time and histories of characters unfold quickly in this story that takes Jesse Neerman from the seventh to twelfth grade in high school, to being appointed to the bench midlife, his limerence holding him captive to a dream that could never be.

Tuesday, February 28, 2023

NO STRINGS

Appel's "Strings" is one of the better written stories in this Beach House collection. Just look at how succinctly he sets the stage in the first sentence:

"RABBI CYNTHIA FELDER WAS NEWLY MARRIED, and in her pulpit only six months, when a former lover asked to borrow the sanctuary." 

Note the use of caps in the opening phrase, like a headline, screaming "emancipated woman here" and a rip in the conventional fabric of society. All at once we have Gays, Lesbians, and Koreans gathering in her tabnernacle, but the thought of 400 musicians (cellists!) invading her sanctuary seemed the height of effrontery. At the pinnacle of this impudence was the fact that a female was the ultimate arbiter of the use of God's space.

The description of the new music concert led by ex-lover Jacques Krentz was so accurate that Appel surely must have seen such a spectacle. I've seen many such concerts of new music where the conceptual framework challenges musical convention leaving the audience stunned, and rendering the musicians somewhat incoherent.

"No Strings" was the name of a musical by Richard Rodgers, and while the title suggested a romantic relationship with no obligations, it also described an orchestra for the musical that had no string instruments in the ensemble. For some reason, this story title reminded me of that musical, and there is a tone in Appel's writing that "Strings" seems to resonate metaphorically for Jacques remaining attached to Cynthia, the newly married rabbi. But instead of NO Strings, it is actually ALL STRINGS, 400 Cellists!

This story emerges as a comedy and a statement of a world fluctuating in artistic and social change, Appel leaves us smiling, perhaps thinking the world isn't so bad after all. It's a tight, well-knit narrative, attempting to celebrate the grandiose, and recognizing that bigger is not necessarily better.


Monday, February 27, 2023

WILL TRY ONE MORE TIME

Will try one more time to make this blog work. Will read strings tonight and write blogpost tomorrow

WHY---INDEED, WHY?

 "WHY? "is a good question to ask yourself. 

I believe you are mistaken that the story "resonated' with me. I wanted to explore it to see why, in my estimation, it was flawed. This is a story in which Appel is showing off how bright and intelligent he is. I find the dialogue and story line somewhat tedious. I was a bit annoyed that he was using the battle between the couple to take us to no resolution. 

As for the sections, it seems obvious from his cinematic ending that they are the equivalent of "scenes" in a film. This is not a practice exclusive to Appel. Different authors use similar devices to denote either the passage of time or the ending of one scene and the beginning of another.

Even so, I can't concoct a better ending than the one Appel offers, even though it leaves me a little bit angry that I bothered to finish reading this affair of the tragic sadness of hedghogs...indeed, Josh and Adeline are just a couple of hedgehogs marinating in the tears of their own sad lives.


Sunday, February 26, 2023

LAST QUESTION

Why did Appel leave the ending of La Tristesse Des Herrisons on a cliffhanger? At the end of the story, he leaves us, as you say, in a "polaroid moment." This is quite an unusual, though not uncommon, way of ending a story. Why did Appel end the story in this manner?

I'd also like to ask why Appel used sections in the story. The divisions convey a sense of progression around Josh's relationship with Adeline, but it didn't resonate with me the same way it resonated and interested you.



Saturday, February 25, 2023

FARE THEE WELL...

Sorry that EINSTEIN'S WRITERS DEN didn't turn out to be your cup of tea.

I thought you were doing well, and that you made some very fine observations and comments. I just couldn't understand why you wouldn't carry on a conversation.

I won't kill this Blog. It can hang for a while. 

I'll check it from time to time to see if you post anything. 

I think there was a lot you could learn from Appel, as he has good points and serious deficits. We learn can from his mistakes as well as his fine points.

Even though you stop contributing to this Blog, I may continue my reading of Appel. It has been a good source for a number of writing techniques and devices, including determining differences between narratives and plots. 

Some of Appel's technique is naked and brutal---signs of his conflict between emotion and intellect. I'm sorry we didn't get to "Limerence," as that story defines a psychological condition that wasn't officially recognized until recently by the Psychiatric Association. It was my affliction all through elementary, middle school and high school, but I thought it was just life.

Please keep writing. You do have something to say. Maybe someday you will discover what it is. 

Yes. Even now.

Keep writing, and it will come through.



DENOUMENT

I'm not providing the dialogue you desire. May we please pause this project?